METHOD

Panel Discussion

Students are assigned different roles and debate an issue from their given positions. They prepare and present arguments, viewpoints, and interests.

This method develops students’ ability to empathise, argue from a specific perspective, and gain insight into complex issues.

1

Introduce an issue that can be viewed from multiple perspectives and/or involves potential conflicts of interest.

2

Assign each student or group a role, e.g., politician, business owner, climate activist, researcher, or citizen. Provide, or ask students to help create, a role description outlining the person’s background, position, and interests.

3

Students read their role descriptions and may add further details about their role’s position and interests.

4

They research the issue using articles, videos, or reports to find facts and examples that support their arguments.

5

Students prepare and note their arguments while anticipating possible counterarguments from others, so they can effectively prepare counter-arguments.

6

Students debate in groups or the whole class, taking turns presenting their viewpoints.

7

Summarise with the students:

  • What was easy or difficult about defending a particular viewpoint?

  • Which arguments were most convincing—and why?

  • Did you change your opinion during the debate?

  • Have you gained new insights from the discussion?

 

Didactic tips:

  • Students can choose their own role or be assigned a challenging role that differs from their own opinion.
  • One or more students who need extra challenge can take on the role of facilitating the role-play.
  • After the panel discussion, students can write an article, debate piece, or create a video to argue their case.
  • Instead of a panel discussion, the focus can be on negotiating or finding a common solution — for example, a plan of action or a new bill.
Tags: Argueing, debating, listening
You must be logged in to use this feature.
EngageInvestigateAct

MODES OF ORGANISATION:

  • Group
  • Whole class

TOOLS / MATERIALS:

  • Optional: role descriptions
  • Optional: fact sheets about the issue
  • Optional: props or name tags to support roles